NHS: Not Hiring Smart?


NHS: Not Hiring Smart?


In the news recently you might have seen that 1,500 job offers for Junior Doctor positions across the UK have been withdrawn. There is a nationally coordinated recruitment system in place for Junior Doctors across 20 specialities (such as Cardiology, Endocrinology etc.). This is known as ST3 Recruitment and is run by the Royal College of Physicians. Once Trainees have received approximately 2 years of specialist training, they apply to roles in order to continue their training and development.

At an interview stage, they are required to provide an eligibility folder (to prove they are eligible to work in the UK and have gone through the application process) and an evidence folder (achievements, qualifications and publications). Six different interviewers then ask questions about the trainees' experience and evidence folder in order to mark their suitability. All candidates marked as 'appointable' are then ordered from highest score to lowest score, with the highest scorers guaranteeing their first preference out of the available and relevant vacancies.

So, where has this system gone awry? Well, once the scores have been counted up, the data for a series of applicants was transferred to another programme. This transfer is what corrupted the data and lead to some incorrect scores. The error was not picked up and there are no standard checks in place to ensure data has been transferred accurately as this system hasn't failed in the past. Jobs were then offered to the trainees according to the corrupted data. Some of these scores were accurate, some were not. Understandably in the medical sector, it is crucial that people who are ill-qualified don't receive the jobs. Hence, when this mistake was uncovered, the 1,500 job offers were withdrawn with immediate effect.

This has caused considerable uncertainty, anguish and criticism from all of those affected. There are a number of genuine, life-changing implications of this. They may lose the dream opportunity they have been training up to for years, other people have already relocated and put down deposits on houses only to be told that they no longer have a job offer.

Rupert Simpson had received a job offer to work in cardiology in a London practice. In an interview with the BBC, he said "I'm getting married next month, and my fiancée lives and works in London - it would be very difficult for us if I don't receive another offer in London...For years I've been moving from contract to contract as a junior doctor, so the idea of having a stable job for five years was amazing."

The Royal College of Physicians says this is human error, however, the error might be in using a system to collate the data in the first place. An interview should be more than a tick box exercise and it seems like this relatively elitist yet basic job allocation method might be ignoring the 'human' aspect of interviews. Not to mention there are data anomalies such as what has occurred in this example. Why can't we use a traditional interview structure for Doctors? Whilst it could result in temporal and financial inefficiencies, surely each practice would benefit from selecting their Doctors, rather than the other way around?


ElliotI joined Mattinson Partnership in September 2016, having graduated from Queen Mary, University of London with a BSc (Hons) in Environmental Science. I started off working as a resourcer within Dominic's Built Environment team and I was promoted to Consultant in the Spring of 2017. I now cover BIM, Structural and Civil Engineering. My background is in insurance sales, where I gained experience in client and customer relations, which I have built upon in my time in recruitment. In my spare time, I like to stay active and I am known amongst my peers as a fantasy football guru.


Back to blog
Log In.

Apply now:


Please note: we only accept .doc, .docx and .pdf files

Refer A Friend:


London Wildlife Trust.

We are proud partners of The London Wildlife Trust, a charity dedicated to protecting the wildlife and wild spaces of London by driving environmental projects throughout the city. Our team often get involved at ground level in Wild Workdays by helping to maintain and restore treasured spaces and land… we love to get our hands dirty! We also run multiple interactive workshops, providing their conservation trainees with invaluable career advice and insights into the environmental sector to prepare them for employment. Most recently, we worked with young people taking part in their Keeping it Wild programme, which engages young people from backgrounds currently under-represented in nature conservation.

Royal Town Planning Institute.

The RTPI represents planning professionals in the UK and Ireland and aims to encourage the development of vibrant and prosperous places and communities. Our Senior Consultant Freddie enthusiastically attends the annual Planning Convention, and we host several events throughout the year to show our support, including drinks networking and a literal pub quiz. We also keep in close contact with our friends down under, at the Planning Institute Australia and New Zealand Planning Institute. In addition, we sponsor the London Planning Summit, an event designed to address the biggest challenges facing the industry. This is our opportunity to stay on top of the latest changes in town planning by meeting with other key professionals in the sector, while celebrating our achievements.

Land Securities Group Plc.

One of our clients, LandSec, are the clever people behind Girls Can Do It Too, an initiative designed to encourage girls to consider a career in construction. Currently, only 11% of the construction workforce are female, and LandSec are attempting to increase this number by providing education and engagement projects and workshops for girls aged 11-13. Featuring workshops on demolition and tower building, as well as challenging the girls to design a planning project of their own (with a focus on budgeting and environmental considerations), LandSec have proven their dedication to addressing the need for diversity in this very male dominated industry. Ruth assists the project by sharing her fascinating insights into the industry and is even on the project judging panel!

Urban Land Institute.

In partnership with Urban Land Institute we are able to play an imperative role in creating a larger and more diverse pool of candidates within the planning & property professions. Working in schools we take part in the Urban Plan Educational workshops programme, which has now reached more than 2,500 pupils in 100 schools since its launch. Alongside more than 200 industry volunteers engaged across the country, we provide invaluable industry & careers advice to students while guiding them through their workshops and helping judge their presentations.

Carbon Footprint.

Carbon FootprintTM works to help organisations offset their CO2 through tree planting and community projects worldwide. By partnering with Carbon FootprintTM, we have planted native trees and shrubs such as Whitebeam, Hazel, Field Maple, Silver Birch, Rowan, Beech, Blackthorn, Holly and Dog Rose to create a Mattinson Forest that spreads across South East England. Carbon FootprintTM work in conjunction with the Florestal Santa Maria Project (FSM-Redd Project), designed to reduce deforestation in the Amazonian Rainforest. So, for every tree we plant in the UK we guarantee a tonne of CO₂ offset in Brazil too. Carbon FootprintTM have allowed us to not only do our bit for the environment but also commemorate moments of growth for our clients and candidates.